Scare 2 Die! (VCD) (Hong Kong Version) VCD

Now, when you hear that the film comes from a Pang underling with many other Pang regulars in support roles and Danny Pang serving as a producer, you may very will conclude that what you'll get with Chien's film is a sort of Pang-lite. And in many ways you're right, that is what you get and that's both a good and a bad thing. Chien's work is light on story and character, factors that many complain about in Pang Brothers films and factors that are a major issue here when Chien tries to rely on narrative to drive the film. His writing simply isn't good enough to go down that road convincingly. However Chien is a solid idea man and a stellar stylist and when he chooses to indulge those urges he is capable of producing some stellar work.

Though the first and third segments each have their solid moments - the gambling piece stars Sam Lee and features a truly gruesome moment that will horrify dog lovers - it is the middle segment where Chien's really hits his stride. The story of a young woman who awakes to find herself in a building populated by cannibals and zombies, the piece plays out almost entirely without dialogue, beginning with an aggressively edited sequence of images that lays out the entire work before going back and playing it out again in more detail. It's a surprisingly effective trick, one that works in much the same way that the original Japanese Ju-On films' tipping the name of the person who would die did: you know where you're going but not how you're going to get there and the tension comes from the route rather than the destination.

Anthology projects are always a mixed bag and this is no exception. It's an inconsistent film, often frustratingly so, but the high points are certainly high enough to mark Chien as a talent worth watching. It he gets the chance to develop his own voice a little bit more he could prove to be something fairly unique.

by Todd Brown - Twitchfilm.net

scare 2 die is separated into three stories, all interrelated but not in a substantial or overt manner. Story one is "Gambling Man", and features Sam Lee as deadbeat mahjong player Kan Au. Even though he's heavily in debt, Kan continues to gamble, and his debt is growing ever larger. His luck changes when he comes into possession of a lucky coin that grants him the ability to pull the "13 Unique Wonders" (an insane winning hand in mahjong) a total of 13 times. The problem is he can only win once per day, and each win usually comes with someone's untimely death. Can he make enough at the mahjong table to pay off his massive debt before the pile of corpses starts to bother him?

As usual, Sam Lee is a fun performer, and "Gambling Man" manages a few moments of tension or cleverness. However, the segment is rather predictable, and feels not unlike one of the minor segments you'd find in a Troublesome Night film - with the added caveat of a lot more gore. scare 2 die seems to take pleasure in serving up fleshy red bits whenever it has the chance, though not to a truly Category III level. The make-up effects are usually too fake or too disconnected to scare or unnerve, and without a really interesting story, the lasting effect is one of mild diversion. But hey, gore is gore. Get it while you can.

Segment two, titled "Running Girl", amps the gore because it has the perfect reason to. Elanne Kong stars as a girl who wakes up, puts on a red button-up shirt and no pants (yow!) and proceeds to find out that everyone in her nearby vicinity has become a flesh-eating zombie. Or at least, they're probably zombies. The film doesn't really tell us if they are but they pretty much have to be, because why else would everyone in her housing estate become grey-skinned flesh-eaters? Obviously perturbed, Elanne runs all over the estate in fear while people chase her trying to eat her heart. Eventually she strikes back by picking up an axe, though there may be far too many zombies for her to take down. Elanne Kong is a petite young woman.

Cub Chien starts "Running Girl" with a quick montage of shock images and quick cuts, relating the entire segment in a fast and confusing manner. Then, the whole segment unfolds again normally, with the story related via normal storytelling. This uncommon technique helps make the segment far more interesting than it should be because the audience spends their time piecing together the story based on the opening montage, matching previous images to actual onscreen development. The worst thing is that the story is hardly substantial in montage or non-montage form, as it's nothing more than a common horror situation given physical, visceral form.

"Running Girl" is entertaining enough on a technical level, as Chien keeps the adrenaline and blood pumping for the segment's full running time. However, the segment suffers from possible omission. scare 2 die's released promotional stills reveal many details and images from the segment that never appear in the final cut of the film. Maybe it was all excised to secure a more teen-friendly Category IIB rating, but the photos hint at stuff that was probably a little more disturbing than the segment's current content. Still, Elanne Kong is a fetching horror victim, and Cub Chien gets plenty of mileage out of her twitchy eyes and long, dark hair. After all, what's an Asian horror film without long, dark hair?

Story three is "Dying Boy", and features Tommy Yuen as a slacker who signs up to be in a reality show called Hak Sei Nei or "scare you to death" (trivia: this is also the Chinese title of the film). Then, scary stuff starts happening to him left and right, which he believes must be the reality show people messing with him. Meanwhile, he returns home to his grandfather and encounters more potential frights, most having to do with Chinese cultural traditions, which means it may not make total sense to everyone who tunes in. Then again, the segment may not make that much sense anyway, because it abandons logic for a continuing parade of horror film technique.

Oddly, the last segment may actually be the most haunting because it references actual Chinese customs and superstition, and takes place in a genuinely scary place that doesn't need much maniuplation to appear scarier. Anybody can freak out people in a hospital bathed in blood, but actual rundown Hong Kong housing estates are downright creepy with the right lighting or camera angles. Add in an ppearance by Hau Woon-Ling (the scary old lady from ten trillion Hong Kong movies), and some decent cinematography and lighting, and you have a half-hour that's more interesting than actually boring - though the ratio of interest to boredom is debatable. It may all depend on how frightening one finds Chinese superstitions and empty housing estates.

Overall, scare 2 die is a minor little diversion that never pretends to be more than it is. It purports no meaning or pretension, and instead tries to shock, scare, and scare some more - with its success predicated on just how susceptible a person is to the usual Pang Brothers scare tactics of shock images, loud sounds, and scenes that take place in elevators (the last segment, in particular, is elevator-o-rama). That said, scare 2 die won't make instant Hong Kong horror fans out of anyone, as it's simply too minor and disconnected, and its lack of a substantial story makes it throwaway. The film is ultimately best reserved for people who like to experience some minor frights, or enjoy seeing fresh idols like Elanne Kong run around with an axe while wearing only an oversized men's shirt. Given Kong's recent surge in local popularity, the above image probably qualifies as a genuine selling point. Time to get in line.

by Kozo - LoveHKFilm.com