Tae Guk Gi: The Brotherhood of War (Special Edition)/Shiri (DVD) (US Version) DVD Region 1

Believing that the future of the family lies with his younger sibling, the simple cobbler Lee Jin-Tae (Jang Dong-Gun) works out a deal with his superior officer: if he wins the Medal of Honor, his brother Jin-Seok (Won Bin) gets sent home. But for Jin-Tae to take home the medal, he starts volunteering for increasingly dangerous missions, much to the confusion of his younger brother. Even worse, Jin-Tae’s noble aim soon corrupts him, as he begins loving the idea of playing the hero a little too much. Eventually, his promotion to sergeant, the parties thrown in his honor, and the interviews with the media seem to go to Jin-Tae’s head. And as a result of this newfound fame, he starts to exhibit an apparent lack of regard for the fiancée (Lee Eun-Ju) he left back home. This change in behavior causes a rift between the brothers, one that will have dramatic consequences for both their lives as history’s “Forgotten War” heats up.

Shot in a style that is strongly reminiscent of Saving Private Ryan and Band of Brothers, Taegukgi goes to great lengths to show the horrors of war in graphic fashion. Limbs get blown off, booby-trapped bodies explode, and surprise attacks abound, creating a strong sense that anyone (well, anyone except the leads, of course) can die at any moment. And while the jerky shooting style may put off some viewers, I found that the technique works well in highlighting the chaotic nature of battle, effectively inserting the audiences into the frontlines right along with its protagonists.

Could the film have done some things better? Certainly. The frame story involving scenes set in the present does add a touch of historical gravitas to the proceedings, but in some ways, I found that it works against the suspense of the narrative: it would be nice to worry about who will die, not just why or how. And yes, there’s a high melodrama quotient in the film, but fans of Korean cinema will likely already be familiar with this convention and accept it as is.

And really, the film isn’t a mindless affair, but a surprisingly nuanced, complicated picture of the Korean War. Certainly, one could argue that the depictions of the North Koreans and the Chinese are exceedingly unflattering, but the way in which the film’s “heroes” are portrayed goes a long way in balancing things out. As we follow the South Korean forces, we watch their descent into darkness, as their brutality soon turns into out-and-out war crimes Although in many ways, Taegukgi is earmarked as a commercial crowdpleaser, I found that it had a little more substance than most popcorn films in telling its tale of two warring ideologies and the common people destroyed by it.

By Calvin McMillin